Why Diets Fail: What Losing More Than 11 Stone Taught Me

My interest in weight loss did not begin with a diet book, a training course or a sudden desire to become thin. It began with throat cancer, and an unexpected experience that left me asking: does rapid weight loss make you hungry?

In 2007, I weighed around 21½ stone. During twelve weeks of cancer treatment, my throat became so sore that eating was extremely difficult. Unsurprisingly, I lost weight, around seven stone from memory. What surprised me was not the weight loss itself. After about 48 hours, I no longer felt hungry. I was eating very little, yet I was not spending every waking hour dreaming about food. The hunger seemed to have switched off.

Does Rapid Weight Loss Make You Hungry?

The question that stayed with me was simple: does rapid weight loss have to make you hungry? That experience eventually changed the way we approached hypnotherapy for weight loss.

I am not suggesting cancer treatment as a weight loss strategy. Even the diet industry has not become quite that desperate.

Losing the Weight Was Only Half the Puzzle

Over the following five years, most of the weight returned. Eventually I was back to about 20½ stone.

I was not particularly distressed about my size. I was all right with it, to be honest. What bothered me was that I could not explain what had happened, and I have never been very good at leaving a puzzle alone.

At the time, the accepted advice appeared straightforward. Lose weight slowly. Avoid fat. Eat breakfast to start your metabolism. Exercise more. Make small changes and wait patiently while the weight gradually disappears.

These ideas were repeated so confidently that questioning them almost felt irresponsible. Unfortunately, confidence and evidence are not always the same thing.

I spent roughly six months investigating the weight loss industry and reading the available research. I was not looking for another branded diet. I wanted to understand why hunger varied so much and why people so often regained the weight they had worked so hard to lose.

The body can respond to continued calorie restriction by reducing its energy expenditure. Weight loss slows, hunger can increase and the person begins to wonder why they are still making the effort.

Metabolic adaptation can begin early. In one study of women following an 800 calorie diet, resting metabolic rate had already fallen during the first week of restriction and was lower again after three weeks.

This is often the moment when the person is blamed. The diet is apparently beyond criticism, so failure must mean that the dieter lacks motivation or willpower.

I see it differently.

All Diets Work, and There’s the Rub

Any eating regime that consistently creates an energy deficit can produce weight loss. The real question is whether an ordinary human being can continue following it while working, socialising, dealing with stress and living around other people who insist on eating biscuits.

If someone is hungry, miserable and preoccupied with food, telling them that the diet works perfectly well when followed is not particularly helpful. So does walking to Scotland, but most people would still prefer the train.

Research comparing different diets has found that adherence can matter more than the precise balance of fat and carbohydrates. People who followed their assigned plan most closely generally lost more weight, regardless of which particular diet they had been given. The A TO Z weight loss study is one example.

Exercise was another part of the accepted answer. Exercise is enormously valuable for health, fitness, mood and strength, but its contribution to weight loss is often overstated. As I explain in my article about exercise and weight loss, people can become significantly fitter without seeing the change on the scales they expected.

The Myth of Losing Weight Slowly

One of the most illuminating papers I found was published in the New England Journal of Medicine in 2013. It examined widely accepted beliefs about obesity and separated established facts from assumptions and outright myths.

One of those myths was that rapid weight loss inevitably produces worse long term results than gradual weight loss. The available evidence did not support that claim. A later randomised trial comparing rapid and gradual weight loss also found that the rate of loss did not affect the proportion of weight regained over the following 144 weeks.

That does not mean rapid weight loss is always better or appropriate for everyone. Reckless dieting remains reckless dieting, however fashionable somebody makes it sound. It means that the blanket instruction to lose weight slowly was not the scientific certainty we had been led to believe.

The usual explanation was that gradual weight loss gave people time to change their habits. That made some sense, except that changing behaviour was already my job. I was a hypnotherapist.

Rather than waiting several months and hoping that new behaviours might emerge, why not address those behaviours directly?

Testing a Different Approach

After completing my research, I devised an eating plan of my own. I followed it alongside five women who wanted to lose weight.

Six people do not constitute a clinical trial. I was testing whether my reasoning worked for us, not attempting to rewrite medical textbooks.

Nevertheless, we took it seriously. Our weights were recorded at the beginning and end. The weigh ins were filmed, witnessed and signed off by a GP.

Over seven weeks, all six of us lost weight. I still retain the records, but the more interesting result was what we did not experience.

We were not hungry.

Within the first week, before individual hypnotherapy began, the participants reported that the cravings and persistent hunger they expected from dieting had largely disappeared.

The key dietary change was the removal of sugar during the structured eating days, apart from sugars naturally present in fruit and vegetables. We also changed when and how often we ate. There was no obsessive weighing of food and no requirement to spend the day counting individual calories.

I am deliberately not publishing the complete method because the eating plan is still used by therapists at the Surrey Institute of Clinical Hypnotherapy. However, this was not a conventional calorie restricted diet that left people staring resentfully at a lettuce leaf while pretending it was dinner.

People ate proper, substantial and satisfying food.

The Fridge, the Freezer and the Spare Buttock

I explained the basic idea using a fridge and freezer metaphor.

The fridge represented the energy that was readily available to the body. The freezer represented stored energy. If we continually refilled the fridge, there was little reason for the body to visit the freezer.

When the fridge became full and more energy arrived, it had to go somewhere. The body effectively went to Curry’s, bought another freezer and installed it in the other buttock.

It was a simple metaphor, but people could use it without needing a degree in biochemistry.

The eating plan also included deliberate periods of normal eating. From what we observed, the way these periods were arranged mattered. When people separated them across the week, the weight loss often appeared to stop. When the normal eating period remained together, the plan continued to work more consistently.

I could not prove why. My suspicion was that it interrupted the body’s adjustment to continued restriction, while also making the plan considerably easier to live with. Later research into planned breaks from energy restriction has provided some evidence that breaks may reduce metabolic adaptation, although those studies did not use our particular arrangement.

Whatever the precise mechanism, we kept the structure because that was what repeatedly appeared to work.

Michael Mosley and the Arrival of the 5:2 Diet

Years later, the language around intermittent fasting and restricted eating windows became much more familiar.

Michael Mosley’s Horizon documentary, Eat, Fast and Live Longer, was first broadcast in August 2012. I saw it after devising my own eating plan, and it provided some welcome validation that the questions I had been asking were not entirely ridiculous.

The 5:2 diet subsequently became fashionable. Mosley’s approach involved eating normally for five days and restricting intake on two. My approach almost reversed the balance, with the greater part of the week structured around the eating plan and a smaller part allowing normal eating.

I am not claiming that the two approaches were identical. They were not. What interested me was that the idea of deliberately moving between structured eating and normal eating had entered the mainstream after years of people being told to eat less every day and lose weight slowly.

Current research does not show that intermittent fasting suppresses hunger for everybody. Human bodies remain annoyingly reluctant to follow one universal set of instructions. I can only report what happened to me and what we repeatedly observed among our clients. A systematic review and meta-analysis of 17 randomised trials found no clear evidence that intermittent fasting affected hunger differently from continuous energy restriction.

Where Hypnotherapy Fitted In

The hypnotherapy for weight loss addressed the behavioural side of eating.

People do not eat solely because their bodies require fuel. We eat through habit, boredom, emotion, reward and convenience. Sometimes it is the time of day, the company or simply the sight of food that prompts us to eat.

The eating plan and hypnotherapy worked together, addressing physical hunger and the learned behaviours surrounding food.

Over the following years, I worked with more than 400 weight control clients. Results varied, as results always do when human beings become involved, but most clients lost meaningful amounts of weight.

Within approximately two years, I had reduced my own weight from around 20½ stone to about 13 stone. My weight continued to fall more gradually afterwards and, by approximately 2021, I was hovering around 10 stone.

For many years, I continued eating in broadly the same way, sometimes more closely than others.

A Good Eating Plan Is Not Automatically a Successful Programme

We later built an online weight loss programme called Diet Assist. Commercially, it was a disaster. We marketed it badly and tried to turn an interactive therapeutic process into something people could follow largely by themselves. It taught me that information alone is not always enough.

People often need interaction, accountability and an approach that can adapt to their circumstances.

Our therapists still draw heavily upon the eating plan, although my own clinical work now focuses almost entirely on toilet anxiety.

So, Does Rapid Weight Loss Make You Hungry?

It can, but it does not inevitably do so.

My experience taught me that rapid weight loss does not have to mean constant hunger, and gradual weight loss is not automatically more sustainable. The rate at which somebody loses weight is only part of the story.

The more useful questions are whether the way they are eating controls hunger, whether they can live with it and whether the behaviours surrounding food are changing alongside their body.

There is one final irony to all of this.

I am now virtually nil by mouth, another little gift from the treatment for throat cancer rather than the cancer itself. All my nutrition comes through a PEG, largely in the form of Fortisip, which contains considerably more sugar than my original eating plan would ever have allowed.

Life, apparently, had one more joke left.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.